August8
A few months ago I mentioned I was reading Water for Elephants by Sara Gruen.
Well, I finished it ages ago but only now remembered that I said I'd review it.

Overall, I was sadly disappointed.
I really, really wanted to like this book because it held so much promise.
Stop press! Disclaimer ahead…
Okay, I know some people get very passionate about the books (and authors) they love, and very defensive when they're criticised, so I'm just going to preface this post by saying that whatever I thought of the book, Sara Gruen is obviously a successful, bestselling novelist beloved by millions worldwide, and I'm not trying to take that away from her.
However, if I'm not going to sugarcoat what I think of a brand of mascara, I can't really refrain from giving an honest account of my feelings about a novel, can I?
But I'll try not to be unnecessarily brutal.

Okay. So if the setting for Water for Elephants – a travelling circus in America during the Great Depression, during Prohibition, when ordinary Americans were actually dying of starvation, when the concept of 'political correctness' was beyond comprehension, and so on – isn't simply bristling with fodder for the most colourful, fascinating, grotesque, comical, diabolical, heart wrenching and compelling characters, and equally seductive and absorbing plot lines and scenarios, I honestly can't think of one that is.
The richness of Jacob's story should have tumbled off the pages, sweeping the reader up in a cacophany of sensory experiences… the gaudy array of costumes and blinding stage lights, the smell of greasepaint and animal dung, the hammering of workmen. The endless, monotonous clatter of train wheels on tracks.

I wanted to be transported, to lose myself in Jacob's world and deeply engage with the characters and their unfolding stories.
Instead I found my imagination having to work, actively required to imagine the scenery and conjure up mental images to pad out and fill the gaps the author left gaping.
As a result, I quickly tired of doing the work the author should have, and the effort of trying to find anything about any of the two-dimensional characters to engage with quickly gave way to irritation, and indifference.
Water for Elephants, however, is saved from being a total disappointment by Gruen's shifts to Jacob's narration as a 93 year old.
Now this was a character I could feel empathy for and whose account of his circumstances deeply moved me.
If only Gruen's handling of Jacob's recounting of his youth was as skillful as the voice she gives him to express his experiences as a geriatric patient.
Contrary to my expectations of gaining insight into the fascinating life of travelling circuses, this novel instead gave me a better understanding of what it would feel like to be at the very end of your life, looking backward.
It also challenged my belief that, at 93, life is just about waiting for death, and that moving forward is only an option for people with a few decades – rather than a few months, or years – up their sleeves.
***

Sara Gruen being hugged by an elephant on the Water for Elephants movie set
It's interesting. At the start of this post, I was quite disillusioned about Water for Elephants, and wondered how I could review it and keep my desire to pan it in check.
But it writing it, I'm surprised to find that the elderly Jacob's story touched me and changed my perceptions much more than I had realised. And isn't that one of the reasons why we choose to read books about subjects we're interested in learning more about – to change our perceptions?
It reminds me of that saying I heard many, many years ago, and that has always resonated with me – "How do I know what I think until I see what I write?"
So, overall I would give Water for Elephants 3 stars out of 5.
If you have read it, what would you give?
xx Kiki
You may also like: